We Want to Hear From You! What Do You Want to See on the Community? Tell us here!
Forum Discussion
Seeing images that have been starred or commented on by others a folder has been shared with
Apparently, this has been rumbling on since 2018 but instead of resolving it Dropbox just locks the threads claiming to have resolved it! If they have I cannot find out how.
I have paid for Dropbox and have shared a folder with a client so they can star or comment on images they wish to select. This remember is MY Dropbox folder in space I have paid Dropbox for. Now I have discovered that none of their comments or stars are available for me to see.
This is completely bonkers. The most obvious reason to star or comment on images in a shared folder is to SHARE that information. Have I got the wrong end of the stick somewhere and missed some obscure menu or button? If the folders are not able to do anything so basic then I am struggling to see a use for Dropbox going forward.
5 Replies
- Walter
Dropbox Community Moderator
Hey there Immortaleye - thanks for sharing your thoughts on this with us.
Starring files or folders is account specific so you won't be able to see starred files or folders from other members of the shared folder - that's expected.
What you mention about comments though is a bit weird as those should be shown on shared files. Have you ensured that your client is leaving the comments on the same files as the ones you're looking at?
Let us know more and we'll take it from there.
It may be what YOU expect. Absolutely nobody else expects this, as is evident in all the posts on this you have shut down over the years. Nor are comments any use if they can only be seen once you click on the images in question.
If I share a folder of images on MY dropbox account I absolutely expect to see which images documents or whatever have been starred and it is ludicrous to suggest something is 'expected' just because it suits you not to sort an issue.
- Rich
Super User II
Immortaleye wrote:
... it is ludicrous to suggest something is 'expected' just because it suits you not to sort an issue.
One might say it's also ludicrous to expect a feature to do something that it wasn't intended or designed to do.
Starring a file or folder is meant as a way to mark it as a favorite so it's more easily accessible to you. It wasn't designed as a way to mark files for other users. If that's a feature you need then you might find that someone has already suggested it in the Dropbox ideas section where you can vote on it. If no one else has suggested it, you can start a new idea post.
I am having the same problem, i have used this many times in the past and it has worked, i share a folder and the client stars the elections and makes comments, then i can see her selections but recently it just works sometimes and not others, this is a problem and isnt because its not meant to be used this way because a lot of the time it dows work. I just shared it with two people next to me one of them i can see all the stars and comments and the other i cannot, please explain they both have different accounts to me.
Also when i send a client the files you give them this option to star and comment so if what your sayign is true and its not meant to be used this way then why are you making it available? Your resonce does not make sense to me?
